Bitcoin YearsThe Atlas
Menu

Bitcoin Years › History › Cypherpunk archive

1976 – 2009

Before Bitcoin The Cypherpunk Archive

Bitcoin did not appear from nowhere. Before it there were three decades of cryptography, a movement that believed privacy had to be built in code, and a series of digital cash experiments that each solved part of the problem. This is that story, told through the original papers, emails and blocks.

How to read this page: every record links to its original source and is labelled by source type. Dates marked “c.” are approximate. A shared idea is not proof that one person influenced another; we say so only where a document shows it.

Chronological map of the ideas before Bitcoin, 1976 to 2009, in four threads. The same records are listed in full below.Act IAct IIAct IIIIV · V197619801984198819921996200020042008Keys & signaturesNovember 1976: Diffie and Hellman: New Directions in CryptographyFebruary 1978: RSA: a practical way to sign and encrypt1982: Chaum: blind signatures for untraceable paymentsOctober 31, 2008: Satoshi Nakamoto: Bitcoin P2P e-cash paperJanuary 8, 2009: Bitcoin v0.1 releasedJanuary 12, 2009: Block 170: Satoshi sends 10 BTC to Hal FinneyPrivacy & digital cash1982: Chaum: blind signatures for untraceable payments1988: May: The Crypto Anarchist ManifestoSeptember 1992: The founding meeting and the Cypherpunks listNovember 1992: The manifesto reaches the listNovember 15, 1992: Finney: Why RemailersJanuary 1, 1993: Finney: Protecting Privacy with Electronic CashMarch 9, 1993: Hughes: A Cypherpunk's ManifestoOctober 15, 1993: Finney: Detecting Double Spendingc. 1994: DigiCash tests eCash on the internet1998: DigiCash goes bankruptProof of workMarch 28, 1997: Back announces hashcashNovember 1998: Wei Dai: b-moneyc. 1998: Szabo designs bit goldAugust 2002: Hashcash: A Denial of Service Counter-MeasureAugust 15, 2004: Finney launches RPOWDecember 2005: Szabo publishes 'Bit gold'October 31, 2008: Satoshi Nakamoto: Bitcoin P2P e-cash paperJanuary 3, 2009: Block 0: the genesis blockJanuary 8, 2009: Bitcoin v0.1 releasedJanuary 11, 2009: “Running bitcoin”Timestamps & hash chainsApril 1980: Merkle: hash trees for public-key protocols1991: Haber and Stornetta: how to time-stamp a digital documentOctober 15, 1993: Finney: Detecting Double SpendingNovember 1998: Wei Dai: b-moneyc. 1998: Szabo designs bit goldDecember 2005: Szabo publishes 'Bit gold'October 31, 2008: Satoshi Nakamoto: Bitcoin P2P e-cash paperJanuary 3, 2009: Block 0: the genesis block

Four threads of ideas, one dot per record. Tap a dot to jump to it. The threads are a reading aid, not a family tree.

Act I1976–1985

The problem of trust

Before anyone could build money on a network, cryptographers had to solve a quieter problem: how two strangers can prove things to each other without sharing a secret.

Publication#

Diffie and Hellman: New Directions in Cryptography

Whitfield Diffie, Martin Hellman

Two Stanford researchers show that people can agree on a secret, and sign messages, without ever meeting to exchange a key. Public-key cryptography begins here.

Keys & signatures
Publication#

RSA: a practical way to sign and encrypt

Ron Rivest, Adi Shamir, Leonard Adleman

The RSA paper turns the public-key idea into a working system for encryption and digital signatures. The method was devised in 1977; the paper appeared in Communications of the ACM in February 1978.

Keys & signatures
PublicationWhite paper ref. [7]#

Merkle: hash trees for public-key protocols

Ralph Merkle

Ralph Merkle describes trees of hashes that let one short value vouch for many pieces of data. The Bitcoin white paper cites this 1980 paper (reference 7) for the tree that summarises a block's transactions.

Timestamps & hash chains
Publication#

Chaum: blind signatures for untraceable payments

David Chaum

David Chaum shows how a bank can sign a digital coin without seeing it, so it cannot later link the coin to the person who spends it. Presented at Crypto '82; the proceedings were printed in 1983.

Privacy & digital cashKeys & signatures
Act II1988–1993

The movement

A small group of engineers, mathematicians and activists decided that privacy in the digital age would not be granted by law. It would have to be built.

Concept#

May: The Crypto Anarchist Manifesto

Timothy C. May

“A specter is haunting the modern world, the specter of crypto anarchy.”

Timothy May writes a one-page manifesto predicting that strong cryptography will change how people trade and organise. He later said it dated back to mid-1988 and was handed out at the Crypto '88 conference.

Privacy & digital cash
PublicationWhite paper ref. [3]#

Haber and Stornetta: how to time-stamp a digital document

Stuart Haber, W. Scott Stornetta

Two researchers show how to prove when a document existed by linking each record to the hash of the one before, so the past cannot be quietly rewritten. Three of the eight references in the Bitcoin white paper are their work.

Timestamps & hash chains
Event#

The founding meeting and the Cypherpunks list

Eric Hughes, Timothy C. May, John Gilmore

A group meets in the San Francisco Bay Area in September 1992; May later wrote that he read his manifesto there. The Cypherpunks mailing list grows out of these meetings. The name is widely credited to Jude Milhon.

Privacy & digital cash
Mailing list#
From: Timothy C. MayTo: Cypherpunks listDate: November 1992

The manifesto reaches the list

Timothy C. May

May posts the Crypto Anarchist Manifesto to the Cypherpunks list in November 1992 with a short note on its history. The message survives in public list archives.

Privacy & digital cash
Mailing list#
From: Hal FinneyTo: Cypherpunks listDate: November 15, 1992

Finney: Why Remailers

Hal Finney

Hal Finney, a programmer on PGP, explains why anonymous remailers matter: they hide who is talking to whom, not just what is said.

Privacy & digital cash
Essay#

Finney: Protecting Privacy with Electronic Cash

Hal Finney

Finney argues that Chaum-style digital cash could protect everyday privacy, and explains how it works for non-specialists.

Privacy & digital cash
Publication#

Hughes: A Cypherpunk's Manifesto

Eric Hughes

“Cypherpunks write code.”

Eric Hughes sets out the movement's creed: privacy is not secrecy, nobody will hand it to us, and those who want it must write the software that provides it.

Privacy & digital cash
Mailing list#
From: Hal FinneyTo: Cypherpunks listDate: October 15, 1993

Finney: Detecting Double Spending

Hal Finney

Fifteen years before Bitcoin, Finney discusses the problem that would define it: stopping the same digital coin from being spent twice.

Privacy & digital cashTimestamps & hash chains
Act III1994–2005

The experiments

One idea after another tried to turn cryptography into money. Each solved part of the puzzle. Each left something unsolved.

Prototype#

DigiCash tests eCash on the internet

David Chaum

Chaum's company DigiCash runs a public trial of its eCash software with a play currency called CyberBucks. Real banks later issue eCash, but every coin still depends on the issuing bank.

Privacy & digital cash
Mailing list#
From: Adam BackTo: Cypherpunks listDate: March 28, 1997Subject: [ANNOUNCE] hash cash postage implementation

Back announces hashcash

Adam Back

Adam Back proposes making each email cost a little computing work: easy to check, costly to fake in bulk. The aim is fighting spam, not making money, but the mechanism is proof of work.

Proof of work
Event#

DigiCash goes bankrupt

David Chaum

DigiCash files for bankruptcy. The technology worked, but a cash system that needs a company and partner banks can also end with them.

Privacy & digital cash
ProposalWhite paper ref. [1]#

Wei Dai: b-money

Wei Dai

Wei Dai describes money run by its users: coins created by solving computational problems and a ledger kept by participants rather than a bank. It was never built, but it is the first reference in the Bitcoin white paper.

Proof of workTimestamps & hash chains
Concept#

Szabo designs bit gold

Nick Szabo

Nick Szabo designs a scheme for scarce digital objects: each one is a proof-of-work solution, timestamped and linked to the one before. It was never implemented.

Proof of workTimestamps & hash chains
PublicationWhite paper ref. [6]#

Hashcash: A Denial of Service Counter-Measure

Adam Back

Back's technical paper describes hashcash in full. The Bitcoin white paper cites it (reference 6) as the basis of its proof-of-work system.

Proof of work
Prototype#

Finney launches RPOW

Hal Finney

Reusable Proofs of Work: a server swaps a hashcash token for a signed token that can be passed on. The server ran on secure IBM hardware whose code anyone could check, but there was still one server.

Proof of work
Publication#

Szabo publishes 'Bit gold'

Nick Szabo

Szabo writes up bit gold on his blog, Unenumerated, years after first designing it. The post describes the chain of proofs of work and a registry of who owns them.

Proof of workTimestamps & hash chains
Act IV2008

The missing piece

In October 2008 a short email arrived on a cryptography mailing list. Its references point back to the earlier acts of this story.

Mailing list#
From: Satoshi NakamotoTo: Cryptography Mailing ListDate: October 31, 2008Subject: Bitcoin P2P e-cash paper

Satoshi Nakamoto: Bitcoin P2P e-cash paper

Satoshi Nakamoto

“a new electronic cash system that's fully peer-to-peer, with no trusted third party”

An email to the Cryptography Mailing List announces a nine-page paper and a new kind of electronic cash.

Keys & signaturesProof of workTimestamps & hash chains
In our Primary sources archive →

The white paper’s eight references

Satoshi Nakamoto cited eight earlier works. Four of them appear in this story; tap one to go back to it. Half of the list is about timestamping, which shows how much of the design rests on that idea. A citation shows what the author read, not everything that shaped the design.

  1. [1] W. Dai, “b-money”, 1998 → Wei Dai: b-money
  2. [2] H. Massias, X.S. Avila, J.-J. Quisquater, secure timestamping service, 1999
  3. [3] S. Haber, W.S. Stornetta, “How to time-stamp a digital document”, 1991 → Haber and Stornetta: how to time-stamp a digital document
  4. [4] D. Bayer, S. Haber, W.S. Stornetta, time-stamping efficiency and reliability, 1993
  5. [5] S. Haber, W.S. Stornetta, “Secure names for bit-strings”, 1997
  6. [6] A. Back, “Hashcash – a denial of service counter-measure”, 2002 → Hashcash: A Denial of Service Counter-Measure
  7. [7] R.C. Merkle, “Protocols for public key cryptosystems”, 1980 → Merkle: hash trees for public-key protocols
  8. [8] W. Feller, An Introduction to Probability Theory and its Applications, 1957
The white paper in our archive →
Act V2009

Genesis

Theory became a running network. The first block, the first release and the first transfer between two people are all on the record.

Mailing list#
From: Satoshi NakamotoTo: Cryptography Mailing ListDate: January 8, 2009Subject: Bitcoin v0.1 released

Bitcoin v0.1 released

Satoshi Nakamoto

The first version of the software is announced on the same mailing list.

Keys & signaturesProof of work
In our Primary sources archive →

Read the genesis block yourself

Inside the first block, in the field miners can fill freely, are these bytes:

04ffff001d0104455468652054696d65732030332f4a616e2f32303039204368616e63656c6c6f72206f6e206272696e6b206f66207365636f6e64206261696c6f757420666f722062616e6b73

The first bytes are technical (the block’s difficulty target and length markers); the rest is ordinary text. It matches the front page of The Times of London on January 3, 2009, so the block cannot have been made before that day. Check it on mempool.space.

The people

Who built the ideas

Ten names that recur in this history. Each card links to the records above where that person appears.

Wei Dai

Computer engineer

b-money (1998): money created by computation and kept on a shared ledger. The white paper's first reference.

Wei Dai: b-money

Six systems

From eCash to Bitcoin, side by side

These were not equal systems: some ran for years, some were only proposals. The table compares what each one needed you to trust.

SystemStatusWho must be trustedWhat makes it scarceHow double spending is stoppedPrivacyIn white paper
DigiCash eCashRan commercially, 1990sIssuing bankBank issues coins against depositsBank checks every coin online against a list of spent coinsStrong for the payer (blind signatures)No
HashcashSoftware, 1997NoneEach stamp costs computing workReceiver remembers stamps already seen; stamps are not passed onNot a payment systemYes [6]
b-moneyProposal, 1998Participants or chosen serversCoins created by solving computational problemsEveryone (or the servers) keeps the ledgerPseudonymous keysYes [1]
Bit goldProposal (1998 design, 2005 post)A registry of owners run by a groupChained proof-of-work solutionsOwnership registryNot specifiedNo
RPOWRunning server, 2004One server on secure, checkable hardwareHashcash workThe server refuses tokens already usedServer sees tokens, not namesNo
BitcoinRunning network since 2009No issuer; anyone can run a nodeFixed issuance schedule, paid to proof of workLongest valid proof-of-work chain, public to allPseudonymous, public ledger (weaker than eCash)—

Simplified for comparison. Each system is described in full in its own record above. [1] and [6] are reference numbers in the Bitcoin white paper.

The synthesis

What Bitcoin inherited, and what it changed

Almost every part of Bitcoin existed before 2009. What was new was putting them together so that no single party was needed.

Inherited

  • Public-key signaturesAct I
  • Private digital cash as a goalChaum, Act I–III
  • Proof of workHashcash, b-money, bit gold, RPOW
  • Timestamps and hash chainsHaber–Stornetta, Merkle, bit gold
  • A ledger kept by usersb-money, bit gold (proposed)

Changed

  • No issuer, no server, no registryEvery earlier working system had one party that could fail or be shut down.
  • Proof of work decides the historyWork is not only a cost; the chain with the most work is the agreed record, so double spends are rejected without a referee.
  • Open membershipAnyone can join or leave the network without permission or an identity.
  • Built-in incentiveNew coins and fees pay the people who secure the ledger.
  • A working releaseNot a paper alone: software shipped in January 2009 and has run since.

Read the originals

Source library

The documents behind this page that are not already in our Primary sources archive. Bitcoin-era records (the white paper, the genesis block, v0.1, block 170) live there.

  1. Diffie and Hellman: New Directions in Cryptography November 1976 · Stanford (author's copy) Primary source
  2. RSA: a practical way to sign and encrypt February 1978 · MIT (author's copy) Primary source
  3. Merkle: hash trees for public-key protocols April 1980 · cited in the Bitcoin white paper Academic record
  4. Chaum: blind signatures for untraceable payments 1982 · chaum.com Academic record
  5. May: The Crypto Anarchist Manifesto 1988 · Cypherpunks list archive (venona.com) Archived primary
  6. Haber and Stornetta: how to time-stamp a digital document 1991 · cited in the Bitcoin white paper Academic record
  7. The founding meeting and the Cypherpunks list September 1992 · May's note on the list (venona.com) Archived primary
  8. The manifesto reaches the list November 1992 · venona.com list archive Archived primary
  9. Finney: Why Remailers November 15, 1992 · Satoshi Nakamoto Institute Archived primary
  10. Finney: Protecting Privacy with Electronic Cash January 1, 1993 · Satoshi Nakamoto Institute Archived primary
  11. Hughes: A Cypherpunk's Manifesto March 9, 1993 · activism.net Archived primary
  12. Finney: Detecting Double Spending October 15, 1993 · Satoshi Nakamoto Institute Archived primary
  13. DigiCash tests eCash on the internet c. 1994 · chaum.com eCash archive Primary source
  14. Back announces hashcash March 28, 1997 · Bitcoin Magazine (history of the announcement) Secondary source
  15. DigiCash goes bankrupt 1998 · Wikipedia Secondary source
  16. Wei Dai: b-money November 1998 · weidai.com Primary source
  17. Szabo designs bit gold c. 1998 · Wikipedia Secondary source
  18. Hashcash: A Denial of Service Counter-Measure August 2002 · hashcash.org Primary source
  19. Finney launches RPOW August 15, 2004 · Satoshi Nakamoto Institute Archived primary
  20. Szabo publishes 'Bit gold' December 2005 · Unenumerated (Szabo's blog) Primary source

How this page was made

Every record was checked against the source it links to before it was added. Summaries are in our own words; quotes are short and taken from the original. Source labels: Primary source is the original document at its original home; Archived primary is a faithful copy kept by an archive; Academic record is a published paper known through its citation; Secondary source is a reliable account written later.

Satoshi Nakamoto’s identity is unknown and this page does not guess. A citation in the white paper shows what its author read, not the full list of what shaped Bitcoin. Spotted an error or know a better source? Write to [email protected].

Related: Primary sources archive · The genesis block · The first transaction · A tribute to Satoshi · Glossary