Bitcoin YearsThe Atlas
Menu

Consensus bug · August 15, 2010

The value overflow: 184 billion bitcoin out of nothing

A transaction in block 74,638 created more than 184 billion bitcoin. A fix was out the same evening, and within a day the chain without the bad block had overtaken it.

Block
74,638
Coins created
184,467,440,737 BTC
Fixed in
Bitcoin 0.3.10, the same day
Repaired
Block 74,691, about 15 hours later
Identifier
CVE-2010-5139

Timeline (UTC)

  1. Aug 15, 2010 · about 18:08 UTCJeff Garzik flags “Strange block 74638” on BitcoinTalk: one transaction has two outputs of 92,233,720,368.54 BTC each, spending an input of 0.5 BTC.
  2. About 5 hours 40 minutes laterBitcoin 0.3.10 is released with two new checks.
  3. About 15 hours after the bad blockThe chain built by upgraded nodes passes the bad chain at block 74,691, 53 blocks later, and the bad block drops out of the main chain.

What broke

Bitcoin checked that a transaction did not spend more than it received, but it added up the outputs in a 64-bit number without checking for overflow. Two enormous outputs wrapped the sum around to a small value, so the transaction looked valid and created about 184 billion bitcoin.

How it was fixed

The fix added two rules: no single output may exceed 21 million BTC, and neither may the sum of all outputs. Because it only tightened the rules, it was a soft fork. Nodes that upgraded rejected block 74,638, and miners built a new chain from the block before it until that chain was longer.

Why it matters

It remains the clearest case of Bitcoin’s supply rule being broken by code, and of how it was restored: by people choosing to run different software, not by any authority reversing a ledger.

Sources

← All incidents, vulnerabilities and the stale-block record